Fb formally launched this coverage in late 2016, after censoring an iconic photograph from the Vietnam Struggle as a result of it contained nudity. Nonetheless, the newsworthiness exception evolved into a blanket exception for politicians, together with Trump, which allowed rule-breaking content material to remain on-line as a result of it was thought of within the public curiosity by default. However whereas this announcement seems to finish that blanket safety, it doesn’t eliminate it fully, and it doesn’t deal with in any extra element how Fb will decide whether or not one thing falls underneath the exception.
Who made this determination?
The announcement was authored by Nick Clegg, the corporate’s vp of worldwide affairs, however refers all through to “we.” Nonetheless, it doesn’t specify who at Fb was concerned within the decision-making course of—which is essential for transparency and credibility, given the controversial nature of the choice.
“We all know at present’s determination might be criticized by many individuals on opposing sides of the political divide—however our job is to decide in as proportionate, honest, and clear a approach as doable,” Clegg wrote.
The place will Fb get recommendation?
The announcement additionally says that the corporate will look to “specialists” to “assess whether or not the chance to public security has receded,” with out specifying which specialists these might be, what experience they may carry, or how Fb (or, once more, who at Fb) could have decision-making authority based mostly on their insights. The Oversight Board, which was supposed partly as a approach of outsourcing controversial choices, has already signaled that it doesn’t want to carry out that function.